Rio’s State Public Safety Secretary, José Mariano Beltrame, trudged up the stairs of the Osteria dell’ Angolo restaurant last night. Getting to the top, he leant heavily against the doorframe, as if in great back pain.
Minutes later, however, he was animatedly discussing almost seven years of highs and lows, spent between favelas and his Being John Malkovich-ish headquarters atop Rio’s central train station.
“You have to put the police into the twenty-first century,” he said. “But you don’t have boots or radios. That is this country’s problem”.
Rio police now busier with demonstrators than anything else
Beltrame said he expects public demonstrations to continue, and murmured that he’ll soon implement a new strategy on this count. Though Governor Sérgio Cabral’s administration will be well on its way out at the time of the June-July 2014 World Cup, with a gubernatorial election next October, the Cup final and six other games will be played in Rio de Janeiro, which saw violent protests during the recent Confederations Cup.
Beltrame also announced the creation of an ombudsman’s office in Rocinha, to hear complaints about police abuse. This is the favela where police officers allegedly tortured a laborer to death in July; ten officers have been arrested in conjunction with Amarildo de Souza’s death and 13 more are expected to be indicted. Meanwhile, another favela resident has died in suspicious police-related circumstances, in Manguinhos favela.
Everyone, including the public at large in the OsteRio debate and ISER‘s Pedro Strozenberg, who hosted it, took care to contextualize criticism amid praise for the achievements of Rio’s pacification program, which began in 2008. No one asked about the much-proposed unification of Rio’s military and civil police forces and Beltrame didn’t directly answer specific queries about police abuse or the expressed need for increased dialogue with security forces.
Beltrame was also diplomatic with his own criticisms, pointing the finger above all at “society”. He called for “structural change”.
Still it was clear that the secretary faults the Brazilian judiciary and Rio’s municipal government for many of the difficulties he’s faced over the years.
“You go to a birosca (small bar) to aprehend a caça-níquel (illegal slot machine), and you find that the owner uses illegal hookups for electricity and water, that he has no building permit, that no one is inspecting the joelhos and pastéis (snacks) he’s selling,” Beltrame complained, adding that most of the UPP offices still function in containers because of lawsuits preventing the police from constructing more permanent offices, onsite.
In the Pavão-Pavãozinho favela, he added, he must increase the number of police officers patrolling the area because residents are building skywards, despite city regulations to the contrary.
Beltrame praised the work of the city’s Pereira Passos Institute president Eduarda la Rocque (who was present) with the Social UPP, but said he’d like to see more integration with city agencies. “Public administration doesn’t function in an integrated manner,” he lamented.
Asked about police action against milícias (violent paramilitary groups operating mostly in the West Zone, extorting residents and shopkeepers, monopolizing key resources), he pointed out that the lack of legitimate businesses offering bottled gas and cable TV, for example, lead to the return of such groups, even when arrests occur, using stepped-up investigation and a new federal law that typifies paramilitary crimes.
Beltrame also mentioned the difficulties favelas have with polluted rivers and sewage, a responsibility of the state concession, CEDAE. He said that police officers deal with issues he considers beyond their responsibility, because other institutions aren’t meeting residents’ needs.
At the same time, Beltrame said, the Brazilian judiciary is perhaps overdoing its job. Most of those arrested last week after a teachers’ demonstration downtown have been released by court order. “Those who do the monitoring have more power than those with executive functions,” he said.
The cordial tone of last night’s debate is probably due to the fact that the gubernatorial election campaign is informally already under way, giving rise to fears for the future of pacification. Rio’s state election is very much up for grabs; governor Cabral’s alliance with mayor Eduardo Paes has fallen apart, and the one with president Dilma Rousseff (herself up for reelection) is also shaky. Her Worker’s Party is bent on fielding its own candidate, Senator Lindbergh Farias, instead of supporting Cabral’s party’s choice, vice-governor Luiz Fernando “Pezão” de Souza. Meanwhile, other candidates join the fray, making the most of Cabral’s fragility.
Beltrame helped Cabral to an easy reelection in 2010. But now, in light of continuing street protests, his achievements are more vulnerable to criticism. Continuity is surely at risk. But last night, for most of those present, the value of the secretary’s work was clear, as he enunciated his accomplishments:
- Entry exams for public safety workers, with 400 new recruits being produced a month.
- Reformulation of the police academy and its curriculum, particularly to reflect respect for and information about human rights.
- 8,600 pacification police, with officers circulating from the academy to UPPs, to normal police work. (These are part of a total force of about 50,000 military police. Rio’s civil police force, above all responsible for investigative work, comes to 12,000 officers. The total of 62,000 officers stands in contrast with the 34,526-person –as of 2010 — New York City police force, serving a population of 8 million. According to Beltrame, the narrow alleys of Rio’s favelas require higher police density.)
- Increased police reports, as favela residents turn away from drug traffickers to resolve conflict, with, for example, a fourfold increase in numbers of citizens seeking help at the 15th precinct, in Gávea (near Rocinha).
- Increased arrests and fewer bullets being shot. In the 16th Battalion, in Bonsucesso, the police used 56,000 bullets in 2009. Last year, they used 2,000.
- 35 police pacification units, with only about four or five left to install, directly affecting about 500,000 residents — a number which jumps to 1.5 million when residents of areas contiguous to pacification units are included.
- A formal redefinition of police work, away from warmongering, towards peacekeeping.
Beltrame, who sees himself now “shifting into fifth gear”, noted that his strategic plan reaches beyond the end of Cabral’s term, laying the groundwork for his successor. The question is who, if anyone will use it. While OsteRio attendees, mostly South Zone residents, are willing to consider the subtleties of pacification in light of the chaotic policy that preceded it, this may not the case with most of the state’s voters.
“The UPP isn’t a solution, it’s a possiblity,” noted ISER’s Pedro Strozemberg. “It’s a watershed”.
Here is a Globo report quoting Beltrame on the August 2013 crime stats, which showed significant increases compared to a year earlier.
Once again, informative and to the point, lending perspective to what can be a very emotive topic. Obrigao!
very interesting post. Was his transcribed speech made available to press? I would love to get a copy of it.
Such a shame it all comes down to one guy. I am curious about the “other institutions” who did not carry their weight, the usual Carioca suspects, the futbol establishment, the media, the lassitude of the Church, real estate developers, architects, construction firms — in other words, everyone who has their greedy fingers in the pie.